1.
In the simplest terms, a bad poem is either (a) missing something fundamental or (b) possessed of something that offends a sensibility.
The problems with this understanding should be immediately apparent. What, after all, is truly fundamental to an artform which has gone through so many phases and fashions, evolved into so many sub-strains — where the contemporary critics of now-revered figures so often appear, in retrospect, to be foolishly fixated on long-discarded scruples? All attempts to identify the single essential technical quality that any poem must possess seem doomed to ridicule.
And what weight can we reliably place on the fact that we are, in one way or another, offended? I use the word ‘offended’ pointedly. There are those who would like to differentiate sharply between a purely aesthetic offence — a perceived fault in the artistry of a piece — and an offence of impropriety. For reasons I will go on to explore, this is not a viable distinction.
For now, though, I merely observe that while most people seem to agree that a tremendous quantity of bad poems exist, there is desperately little consensus on how one might go about identifying one.
2.
There are two opposing existential threats to any artform: on the one hand, “anything goes”; on the other, “hardly anything goes”.
In the first case, the definitional boundaries of what constitutes worthwhile examples of the form become so loose that it is no longer associated with any kind of skill or use of technique. Poets have some reason to fear this — the general public’s ability to differentiate between the work of an experienced practitioner and an absolute beginner (or even the last generation of LLMs’ instantaneous output) may be at an all-time low.
In the second case, the qualifying restrictions are either so abstruse or so lofty that almost no range or innovation is permitted, and the art form recedes into itself as it becomes ever more disconnected from people’s lives. (Poets have reason to fear this too).
Arguments about the quality of poems are frequently unproductive because one side views the other as representative of the “anything goes” camp, while the other consider their opponents to belong to the “hardly anything goes” faction. It is depressingly rare for a conversation to involve any substantial unravelling of the precise criteria anyone is using.
3.
I thoroughly enjoyed Harry Cochrane’s scathing review of David Harsent’s Skin in the latest issue of The Little Review. An extract:
Do you like it? Me neither. As a standalone piece, ‘Sub Rosa’ might have found some kind of pungent identity. But by this point, on page 143 of a 193-page book in which there are no standalone pieces, the reader has long been bludgeoned into despair …
It’s a relief when a critic cuts loose like this in response to a book that is elsewhere being spoken of in tones of strained awe. But let’s be honest: it’s trivially easy to adopt this pose, or something like it, with almost any poet or book, and appear discerning. Cochrane lends gravity to his judgement by including some measured analysis of the technical features of Harsent’s poem, but this too is within the reach of any talented English graduate. The positive effects of reading (or listening to) poetry are rarely, if ever, undeniable; it requires some exercise of the reader’s skill to access them — a politeness that may be silently withheld. At the same time, almost every poet will possess tics and habits that are liable to be irritating, while those they don’t can be accused of excruciating dullness.
Without casting any aspersions on Cochrane, then, (contributors to TLR are encouraged to be brief), no great powers of perception are required in order to accuse an Emperor of being naked. It may involve a certain degree of bravery if the poet or their friends have the means to exact revenge on you, but it does not automatically equate to the critic applying a higher-than-normal standard.
4.
The idea of “judging a poem on its own merits” is almost meaningless. A poem’s merits are inextricable from its context — or rather, the reader’s apprehension of that context. The same words in the same order have a different effect and meaning depending on whether they constitute, for example, (i) the work of an established poet reiterating or refining ideas they are known for originating, (ii) an account of or response to real-life events, (iii) an anonymous competition entry encountered after reading dozens of similarly worded poems, (iii) a case of cut-and-dried plagiarism, (iv) the newly uncovered jottings of Jeffrey Epstein, and so on.
Some of these contextual factors can be temporarily negated, or purposefully ignored by the reader, but not all of them. They are innumerable. Most are subtle, impossible to describe or account for. Where it is claimed that a poem is “judged on its own merits” we may generously assume that the person or organisation making the claim means to make an effort to ignore or negate contextual factors that might tip the scales too decisively one way or the other — for example by putting firmly out of mind any strong personal feelings toward an individual or their previous work.
Less generously, we may assume they mean to make no such effort, and considerate it sufficient that no individual factor will be consciously weighed. Our judgement will be fair, they assure us, because our notions of merit are so deeply instilled that we are not even aware where they come from. Which brings me onto:
5.
In general, people who claim their judgement of art is not influenced by politics or ideology are those with a desire to conceal the extent to which politics and ideology influence their judgement of art — very possibly from themselves. They may, with some justification, regard any judgement which is both knowingly and heavily informed by a stipulated political goal to be weak and narrow-minded. They are reluctant, therefore, to understand and express the ways their own ideological commitments steer their thinking, for fear of admitting a limitation they despise in others.
5.
One of the ways a conscious effort is made to scrub political (and other contextual) factors from the critical processes of those afraid of admitting to inherent partiality is by assessing a poem on the basis of similarity in form and feel to other well-respected poems. This is a sort of ideological money laundering operation; the reader/critic claims politics and personal favour never entered their mind, and further that the stature or antiquity of the poetry used as measuring stick puts it beyond politics. (The latter is a bad claim, of course, but certainly the more distant a poem is from a contemporary political milieu, the more work is involved in articulating how the two are connected.)
The secondary effect of this approach, conveniently, is to make the criteria for a good poem almost circular. A good poem is one that sits neatly alongside other good poems; a bad poem is one that deviates. This is an excellent entrenchment from which to open fire at all those who dare to put forward alternative criteria — criteria which might then be adopted by those less familiar with all the ‘good poems’. Which brings me onto:
6.
Power and authority are at stake when we talk about what makes a ‘bad’ or a ‘good’ poem. This is what animates much of the discourse. Without power and authority, the critical judgement of poetry experts has no answer to the popular appeal of Insta-poems and other money-spinning media forms — they are reduced to customers reviewing niche products.
But power and authority is hard-won; genuinely illuminating, convincing evaluations of individual poems and books take time to muster. Meanwhile, there is the constant need to promote interest in those same poems and books, as well as related events.
So shortcuts are taken. Agreement among a small and insular group is presented as widespread consensus. Authority is extended far beyond its natural purview, as when a poet who is successful and well-liked among his coterie, but limited in range, makes pronouncements on the state of the whole scene. Bad poems need to be invented, and need to vastly outnumber good ones, in order for the authoritative critic to have a function. What’s more, the criteria must remain somewhat hazy in order to avoid the average reader learning how to consistently apply it themselves. Periodic trenchant denunciations of work that, to the untrained eye, is remarkably similar in character to that which the same critic praises are a smart move.
By the same token, the real offence committed by those editors and activists who rule out work by avowed political reactionaries, or are overly interested in poets’ claims to membership of an oppressed group is that their criteria are too transparent. They make it too easy to jump through the hoops, and in so doing threaten to mortally wound the power of other editors and critics — which is wielded on the basis that they possess an exceptional capability when it comes to judging poems.
7.
The Worst Poets Club — a touring venture consisting of four best-selling ‘bad’ poets — is set to capitalise magnificently on the inability of the UK poetry community to reflect with much lucidity on its own processes of judgement, such that any criticism of a popular poet can be instantly recast as peevish snobbery. Rebecca Watts’ infamous 2018 article on one of these ‘bad’ poets, ‘The Cult of the Noble Amateur’, is notable in part because Watts was not in any way stepping out of her wheelhouse. She had been asked to review a book. The publisher of the book was well-known for applying, in its selection process, a stricter version of the very critical standards Watts brought to bear in her review. Her confusion was evident; why had Picador’s poetry editor, Don Paterson, entirely rowed back on the values he had previously both vociferously advocated and put into practice whilst in a position of tremendous influence? Paterson’s claim, in a response piece in The Guardian? “I changed my mind.” “I’m not paid to indulge the narrower of my own preferences,” he added.
Now retired from that role, Paterson is back to railing against the state of poetry, suggesting that much of it is nowhere near good enough to be published. This would seem to be an expression of, in his own words, the narrower of his own preferences. And yet, when sternly lecturing publications that wish to disassociate themselves entirely from the ‘gender critical’ movement, he condemns their “refusal to countenance any diversity of viewpoint”. He detests, he says, all ideologies. The effect of his own preferences, were they applied, would place far greater restrictions on diversity of viewpoint than the decisions of the editors he takes issue with. How is that not the true measure of ideological narrow-mindedness?
(NB. This article now has a sequel, ‘What is a ‘bad’ poem exactly? Part 2’.


I found your comments most interesting, not least because I have been thinking about this matter of evaluation for more decades than I like to enumerate.
For me, too much emphasis is placed on what is ‘good’ and too little on what makes a poetic work ‘interesting’.
‘Interesting’ leads to explanation, and ownership of opinion. ‘Good’ leads to authoritative assertion, often supported by quotation without analysis (and subsequent publication in an authoritative outlet).
This is the age of Strictly Come Poetry. There must be worthy contenders! There must be The Best! There must be a show! See them dance! There must be expert judges.
With performance poetry, a true criterion for success (so far as I can see) is audience response. There are poetry performers who have an electric effect on their audience. This is a rare skill. But you need the performer as well as the text. And you need a listening audience.
Unlike page poetry, where anyone who can write can write a poem, and no one will ever know how many people read it, no matter who publishes it. However, we may know how many copies have been sold.
When it comes to incontestable judgement criteria, people still refer to the top of Emily Dickinson’s head. Or to the hairs on the back of Philip Larkin's neck. Oh for a life of Sensations rather than of Thoughts!
Amen to this cogent, timely, and sprightly essay.