Discussion about this post

User's avatar
helen_beaton@icloud.com's avatar

I found your comments most interesting, not least because I have been thinking about this matter of evaluation for more decades than I like to enumerate.

For me, too much emphasis is placed on what is ‘good’ and too little on what makes a poetic work ‘interesting’.

‘Interesting’ leads to explanation, and ownership of opinion. ‘Good’ leads to authoritative assertion, often supported by quotation without analysis (and subsequent publication in an authoritative outlet).

This is the age of Strictly Come Poetry. There must be worthy contenders! There must be The Best! There must be a show! See them dance! There must be expert judges.

With performance poetry, a true criterion for success (so far as I can see) is audience response. There are poetry performers who have an electric effect on their audience. This is a rare skill. But you need the performer as well as the text. And you need a listening audience.

Unlike page poetry, where anyone who can write can write a poem, and no one will ever know how many people read it, no matter who publishes it. However, we may know how many copies have been sold.

When it comes to incontestable judgement criteria, people still refer to the top of Emily Dickinson’s head. Or to the hairs on the back of Philip Larkin's neck. Oh for a life of Sensations rather than of Thoughts!

Penelope Shuttle's avatar

Amen to this cogent, timely, and sprightly essay.

11 more comments...

Ready for more?